Marketing communication
This page contains marketing information
Marketing communication
This page contains marketing information
Hero Banner

Welcome to M&G

Choose your Location, Investor Type and Cookie Preferences

This content is not available for your selected audience. You have been redirected to your attested homepage.

You have been redirected to your attested site.

Running winners: Value investing’s hardest discipline

4 min read 18 Nov 26

By Shane Kelly, Global Value Equities Fund Manager

The value playbook suggests that investors sell when a stock becomes less cheap. However, as some stocks can become more valuable as the facts change, Shane Kelly explains why value investors need patience to hold on to genuine winners. 

Value investing is often described as the art of buying what others do not want.

As contrarian value investors, we are trained to be wary. We dislike crowded stories, stretched valuations and heroic assumptions. We prefer pessimism to euphoria and evidence to excitement.

The familiar value playbook is, in our view, appealingly neat: buy a stock when expectations are depressed. Wait for the market to recognise that reality is better than feared. Sell when the valuation recovers. Move on to the next cheap opportunity.

There is nothing wrong with that framework. Many investments should be sold when the gap between price and value closes. But the danger is treating every winner as simply a cheap stock becoming less cheap. Some winners do something more powerful: they become more valuable as the thesis develops.

That distinction matters.
 

‘Disposition effect’

Markets often take time to change their views. Narratives are sticky. Forecasts adjust gradually. Investors frequently remain anchored to the old story long after the facts have improved.

A business that was once priced for distress may have repaired its balance sheet, improved margins, changed its capital allocation, or found itself in a better industry structure. What began as a valuation opportunity can become a compounding opportunity.

Selling at the first sign of success can therefore be a false discipline. It feels prudent. It locks in a gain. It avoids the discomfort of watching a profit fluctuate. But it may also remove the stock just as the most exciting part of the transformation is beginning.

Behavioural finance helps explain why this is tempting: investors have a well-documented tendency to sell winners too early and hold losers too long – the so-called disposition effect. 

Investors have a well-documented tendency to sell winners too early and hold losers too long.

The structure of equity returns also makes the problem more costly. Research has demonstrated that the best-performing 4% of US-listed companies accounted for the entire net wealth creation of the US stock market since 19261.

For active investors, that is a crucial lesson. Genuine winners are rare. If we are fortunate enough to own one, we should be careful before replacing it with something that is merely optically cheaper.
 

Disciplined decision

Recently, markets have provided good reminders of the persistent returns that stocks can deliver. 

European banks were long dismissed as structurally challenged, but a different interest-rate regime changed profitability, capital returns and investor perception. 

Parts of the technology sector, previously overlooked as ‘dead tech’, have benefited from the AI trade as demand has run up against the constraints in compute capacity. 

Defence companies, such as Germany’s Rheinmetall, that were once treated as ordinary industrial cyclicals have been reappraised as security spending has become more persistent. 

As Figure 1 shows, investors who sold after Rheinmetall’s share price more than doubled in 2022, without assessing whether there had been any change to underlying fundamentals, may have missed out on significant gains in the following years. 

None of this argues for complacency. Running winners does not mean never selling or taking profits along the way. We believe we should sell when a valuation embeds unrealistic assumptions, when management misallocates capital, when balance-sheet risk rises, or when a clearly better opportunity appears.

But we do not believe a stock should be sold solely because its price has risen.

The right question is always forward-looking: what is the prospective risk-adjusted return from here? If intrinsic value is rising, fundamentals are improving, and the market is still anchored to yesterday’s story, holding may be the more disciplined decision, especially in a well-diversified portfolio.

The hardest part of value investing is not buying what is unpopular. It is having the patience to keep owning it when being right has finally become visible. This discipline is as much an art as a science. 
 

1 Hendrik Bessembinder, ‘Wealth Creation in the U.S. Public Stock Markets 1926 to 2019’, February 2020. 

The views expressed on this webpage should not be taken as a recommendation, advice or forecast, nor a recommendation to purchase or sell any specific security. 

The value of investments will fluctuate, which will cause prices to fall as well as rise and you may not get back the original amount you invested. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.  

Related capabilities

Subscribe to insights

Sign up

Related insights